Tuesday, April 12, 2011

Tampa, FL

8:45 a.m.: We set out on the tepid, swamp-like stroll from our hotel to the meeting -- first, a tour of what is now this agency's offices, studio, and editing suites. The old building was once the downtown Tampa police headquarters, including an interrogation room with one-way glass, which is these days the agency's main conference room (outfitted with 2-way glass now, thankfully.)

Next we dove into personal introductions and an overview of the agenda, while I gnawed on a rock-hard scone. The agency is around 30 members (creatives and non-creatives). Despite some clear expertise, I found each member of our designated team to be down-to-earth, humble, open to suggestion, flexible, and very enthusiastic (but not in the annoying way.) They were very much dialed into the passion of UTI -- the Brand Strategist and Creative Director spent 3 hours at the Orlando campus and seemed honed-in on what our students, graduates and instructors are thinking and feeling.

While they under-delivered on food (our lunch was apparently stolen en route to its destination), they over-delivered on creative. Their presentation of an overarching statement for the brand and its seven proposed targets (potential student, influencer, employer, industry partner, current student, and alumni) was supported with comps of print ads, brochures, direct mail, television, radio, a social media play, and more -- including urinal ads, complete with customized flush handles. That last one was about bringing the funny to such an intense meeting -- however, with a review team of four women, the laughs had to be prompted.

My criticisms are that the overarching statement might not be exactly what we are after, in tone and focus -- however I am not convinced that they couldn't get there, and I got the sense that they would be interested in doing so and engaged by the process. The messaging was not fleshed-out among the seven targets -- which, although not a deal-breaker, would have been a big hit with us. They clearly have the skills, tools, and ability to deliver. Although the creative approach was not ground-breaking, it was bold, well-structured design in concept. The thought-process behind the messaging was thorough, and I applaud their effort to take one idea and commit to it.

4 comments:

  1. The "down-to-earth and humble" are two very good qualities to have along with humor, glad they tried at least ;-) As for the food situation, that is no good, I hope you had a jar of emergency almond butter with you! I'm eager to hear what they came up with!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Did they come up with the target audiences?

    Any new angles on Industry's Choice?

    How was the quality of the creative?

    (BTW - it's Josh)

    ReplyDelete
  3. --Posted by: DonutMiser--
    Always pack snacks when traveling, as it has been my experience that Creative Agencies rarely deliver on snacks and lunches, which is crazy to me since "Creatives" like to eat, so you would think it would be all about the donuts and lobster tails...

    ReplyDelete
  4. Food is overrated. I will come back bearing thumb drives galore, containing all agency presentations in gory detail (including the creative). That way we can duke it out over who gets us!

    ReplyDelete