Today it was a brisk walk up the hill to an office on the 9th floor in the heart of the financial district, complete with postcard-worthy views -- it is hard not to have amazing views from any location in this city. Three of the members of an eventual team of five were ready to greet us.
Well, almost ready -- it was hard not to feel like we caught them slightly unprepared. But they were certainly hospitable -- scones and pastries were on-hand, along with my own favorite Peet's coffee. We started the tour around their space, which was somewhat similar in look and feel to our own home office, only larger. (Oh, and in San Francisco.) This agency is big on display boards, and all the work we could see was well-designed. The personalities of the occupants of each office and cube were comfortably displayed, but we got the feeling that none of them had come in to work today.
Each meeting room was named after some kind of failed technology, which was just the kind of northern-Californian humor I would expect. When we got to the war room dedicated to UTI, we were intrigued -- every inch of space was covered with photos and scribbled ideas related to our business and our brand, and the brainstorming that had gone on. By the time we were seated in the presentation conference room, all five team members had arrived. We could see the culled-down version of creative options they had prepared for us on the walls -- not to say it wasn't still a boatload.
The meeting began with the discussion about who and where we are, and the information that is relevant to where we want to go. The statements about us were concise, and focused on our currently established position as Industry's Choice. There is no doubt that this agency has more international experience than any of the others, and this was reflected in their broader view of who we are and how we talk about ourselves. They were certainly strong on brand awareness, but they did not shy away from direct response. I appreciated their focus on our student life cycle, and significant touch points for the brand within it. There was focus on the power of creating brand advocates, especially in our alumni and industry partners.
Our group was a little more subdued today -- chalk it up to jet lag, or possibly information overload. Still, we were able to engage the agency in conversation about testing as well as the collaborative process, just to gain clarity. The mix of personalities around the table was again diverse, but today the engagement was not as forthcoming. Of course, success is not always easy or comfortable. This group had demonstrated capacity, especially in the digital realm. I would not question their ability to deliver in all mediums, and they have expertise where our demographic lives and breathes.
Criticisms: More talking than listening from this group -- not that we were really saying much today. There was a Bay Area, world-weary, jadedness about it all, however it is quite possible that at least one person in that room had been up all night -- and this agency wins the award, hands-down, for the greatest amount of creative execution. Not every idea was on-target, but I liked that they worked up to the very last moment. Considerations: Will they work for us that way, once engaged? And alternately, could the perceived potential for friction prompt us to step up our game?
No comments:
Post a Comment