Creative Peak
Tuesday, February 14, 2012
Saturday, April 16, 2011
San Francisco
Today it was a brisk walk up the hill to an office on the 9th floor in the heart of the financial district, complete with postcard-worthy views -- it is hard not to have amazing views from any location in this city. Three of the members of an eventual team of five were ready to greet us.
Well, almost ready -- it was hard not to feel like we caught them slightly unprepared. But they were certainly hospitable -- scones and pastries were on-hand, along with my own favorite Peet's coffee. We started the tour around their space, which was somewhat similar in look and feel to our own home office, only larger. (Oh, and in San Francisco.) This agency is big on display boards, and all the work we could see was well-designed. The personalities of the occupants of each office and cube were comfortably displayed, but we got the feeling that none of them had come in to work today.
Each meeting room was named after some kind of failed technology, which was just the kind of northern-Californian humor I would expect. When we got to the war room dedicated to UTI, we were intrigued -- every inch of space was covered with photos and scribbled ideas related to our business and our brand, and the brainstorming that had gone on. By the time we were seated in the presentation conference room, all five team members had arrived. We could see the culled-down version of creative options they had prepared for us on the walls -- not to say it wasn't still a boatload.
The meeting began with the discussion about who and where we are, and the information that is relevant to where we want to go. The statements about us were concise, and focused on our currently established position as Industry's Choice. There is no doubt that this agency has more international experience than any of the others, and this was reflected in their broader view of who we are and how we talk about ourselves. They were certainly strong on brand awareness, but they did not shy away from direct response. I appreciated their focus on our student life cycle, and significant touch points for the brand within it. There was focus on the power of creating brand advocates, especially in our alumni and industry partners.
Our group was a little more subdued today -- chalk it up to jet lag, or possibly information overload. Still, we were able to engage the agency in conversation about testing as well as the collaborative process, just to gain clarity. The mix of personalities around the table was again diverse, but today the engagement was not as forthcoming. Of course, success is not always easy or comfortable. This group had demonstrated capacity, especially in the digital realm. I would not question their ability to deliver in all mediums, and they have expertise where our demographic lives and breathes.
Criticisms: More talking than listening from this group -- not that we were really saying much today. There was a Bay Area, world-weary, jadedness about it all, however it is quite possible that at least one person in that room had been up all night -- and this agency wins the award, hands-down, for the greatest amount of creative execution. Not every idea was on-target, but I liked that they worked up to the very last moment. Considerations: Will they work for us that way, once engaged? And alternately, could the perceived potential for friction prompt us to step up our game?
Well, almost ready -- it was hard not to feel like we caught them slightly unprepared. But they were certainly hospitable -- scones and pastries were on-hand, along with my own favorite Peet's coffee. We started the tour around their space, which was somewhat similar in look and feel to our own home office, only larger. (Oh, and in San Francisco.) This agency is big on display boards, and all the work we could see was well-designed. The personalities of the occupants of each office and cube were comfortably displayed, but we got the feeling that none of them had come in to work today.
Each meeting room was named after some kind of failed technology, which was just the kind of northern-Californian humor I would expect. When we got to the war room dedicated to UTI, we were intrigued -- every inch of space was covered with photos and scribbled ideas related to our business and our brand, and the brainstorming that had gone on. By the time we were seated in the presentation conference room, all five team members had arrived. We could see the culled-down version of creative options they had prepared for us on the walls -- not to say it wasn't still a boatload.
The meeting began with the discussion about who and where we are, and the information that is relevant to where we want to go. The statements about us were concise, and focused on our currently established position as Industry's Choice. There is no doubt that this agency has more international experience than any of the others, and this was reflected in their broader view of who we are and how we talk about ourselves. They were certainly strong on brand awareness, but they did not shy away from direct response. I appreciated their focus on our student life cycle, and significant touch points for the brand within it. There was focus on the power of creating brand advocates, especially in our alumni and industry partners.
Our group was a little more subdued today -- chalk it up to jet lag, or possibly information overload. Still, we were able to engage the agency in conversation about testing as well as the collaborative process, just to gain clarity. The mix of personalities around the table was again diverse, but today the engagement was not as forthcoming. Of course, success is not always easy or comfortable. This group had demonstrated capacity, especially in the digital realm. I would not question their ability to deliver in all mediums, and they have expertise where our demographic lives and breathes.
Criticisms: More talking than listening from this group -- not that we were really saying much today. There was a Bay Area, world-weary, jadedness about it all, however it is quite possible that at least one person in that room had been up all night -- and this agency wins the award, hands-down, for the greatest amount of creative execution. Not every idea was on-target, but I liked that they worked up to the very last moment. Considerations: Will they work for us that way, once engaged? And alternately, could the perceived potential for friction prompt us to step up our game?
Thursday, April 14, 2011
Portland, OR
This morning we jumped out of the cab and into a light, drizzling rain in front of the Portland agency, where we were greeted at the door and whisked upstairs by one of the principals. The building was an old refurbished warehouse in the Northwest district of downtown. Once a rundown, crime-ridden neighborhood, this area is now considered desirable.
The space was refreshing in its design. Large, whitewashed cross-beams and open space allowed plenty of light in. The work spaces were well-equipped but minimally furnished, and just beyond the conference table through glass doors was what appeared to be a well-manicured rooftop garden. The refreshments were fine pastries, tea, espresso, carrot-orange juice and sparkling water, tastefully displayed with cherry blossoms and bamboo plates -- understated, yet impressive.
The individuals around the table were even more so. I appreciated right away the experience, depth, and diversity of each member of this assembled team. The conversation was engaging from the start, and keenly focused on UTI.
This group was relentless in their request for supporting materials from us, and never let up on trying to uncover more detail about what we are doing and where we have been. They talked about their visit to the Avondale campus, and they used information from our own research and statements from students and industry partners, along with their own additional investigation, to zero in on who we are -- a state of the union, of sorts -- which was, in my opinion, accurate. Next they outlined some areas of conflict that need resolution. They described specifically what our goals are, which obstacles we need to overcome, and where important areas of opportunity lie.
They proposed three adjectives that described how we would communicate, along with action goals for each -- a brand "filter" of sorts. They then took a paragraph from a recently produced piece of our work and rewrote it -- a powerful demonstration of the direction they were proposing, and a great illustration of how much of our current messaging touts ourselves and leaves out the student, as well as our industry partners and the benefits they bring.
This agency suggested that we have all we need within us -- that who we are now contains the essence of what we want to say about ourselves. They showed the first of the three web clips from the Military microsite as an example of how we might delve deeper into our student profiles to create an authentic inroad to our target audience. They discussed product placement, mobile delivery, reality tv and webisodes, events marketing, high school "street teams", focus groups, and the measuring of results. They showed us their agency's org chart, and finally a six-month time line if we were to engage their services.
I noticed within our team an easy dialogue across the table -- everyone participated actively and comfortably in the conversation, and contributed in different yet relevant ways. I found this group able to answer at length every question we asked. We did not see specific creative execution from this agency, and strangely I did not miss it -- maybe because they spent their valuable time on the true crux of the problem. I was encouraged by the exuberance (and proximity) of their Phoenix-based partner. Unprompted, this team was enthusiastic about the capacity and input of our internal creative and digital teams.
Criticism/concern -- I have only one, and it cuts both ways: this is not an agency with the capacity for non-strategic busywork. Are we ready to commit to working smart, and to taking an active role in the leadership of our brand? This is an agency that will not succeed without our full engagement. If we are hoping for an AOR who will always hand us finished work, no thinking on our part and no questions asked, I would not look to Portland. I, for one, am not. But then, has that worked for us to date?
Oh, and in case you missed this -- Portland recycles.
The space was refreshing in its design. Large, whitewashed cross-beams and open space allowed plenty of light in. The work spaces were well-equipped but minimally furnished, and just beyond the conference table through glass doors was what appeared to be a well-manicured rooftop garden. The refreshments were fine pastries, tea, espresso, carrot-orange juice and sparkling water, tastefully displayed with cherry blossoms and bamboo plates -- understated, yet impressive.
The individuals around the table were even more so. I appreciated right away the experience, depth, and diversity of each member of this assembled team. The conversation was engaging from the start, and keenly focused on UTI.
This group was relentless in their request for supporting materials from us, and never let up on trying to uncover more detail about what we are doing and where we have been. They talked about their visit to the Avondale campus, and they used information from our own research and statements from students and industry partners, along with their own additional investigation, to zero in on who we are -- a state of the union, of sorts -- which was, in my opinion, accurate. Next they outlined some areas of conflict that need resolution. They described specifically what our goals are, which obstacles we need to overcome, and where important areas of opportunity lie.
They proposed three adjectives that described how we would communicate, along with action goals for each -- a brand "filter" of sorts. They then took a paragraph from a recently produced piece of our work and rewrote it -- a powerful demonstration of the direction they were proposing, and a great illustration of how much of our current messaging touts ourselves and leaves out the student, as well as our industry partners and the benefits they bring.
This agency suggested that we have all we need within us -- that who we are now contains the essence of what we want to say about ourselves. They showed the first of the three web clips from the Military microsite as an example of how we might delve deeper into our student profiles to create an authentic inroad to our target audience. They discussed product placement, mobile delivery, reality tv and webisodes, events marketing, high school "street teams", focus groups, and the measuring of results. They showed us their agency's org chart, and finally a six-month time line if we were to engage their services.
I noticed within our team an easy dialogue across the table -- everyone participated actively and comfortably in the conversation, and contributed in different yet relevant ways. I found this group able to answer at length every question we asked. We did not see specific creative execution from this agency, and strangely I did not miss it -- maybe because they spent their valuable time on the true crux of the problem. I was encouraged by the exuberance (and proximity) of their Phoenix-based partner. Unprompted, this team was enthusiastic about the capacity and input of our internal creative and digital teams.
Criticism/concern -- I have only one, and it cuts both ways: this is not an agency with the capacity for non-strategic busywork. Are we ready to commit to working smart, and to taking an active role in the leadership of our brand? This is an agency that will not succeed without our full engagement. If we are hoping for an AOR who will always hand us finished work, no thinking on our part and no questions asked, I would not look to Portland. I, for one, am not. But then, has that worked for us to date?
Oh, and in case you missed this -- Portland recycles.
Wednesday, April 13, 2011
Chicago
Today our power-walk from the hotel brought us (a little late, thanks again to my serious coffee habit) to a quirky high-rise with amazing views out over downtown, the river, and lake Michigan -- a truly awesome location. And of course it is hard to top this city in the sport of dining and other metropolitan perks. It was perfect April weather in the Midwest, and we were excited to see what would unfold.
Our hosts greeted us warmly in the reception area, where a video message welcomed UTI and each of us by name (it looked as though they were expecting 7, instead of 4). The view was dizzying from up that high, and their work areas are light and open (at least on a day like today). After brief introductions around the table they launched in, presenting a video with testimonials and statements describing what they discovered about us after spending time at the Glendale Heights campus. They took some time to point out a lack of consistency and emotional appeal in our past and current marketing materials. (Yes, and no. But then, we know where we've been.)
They believe that the brand should target the student, and that to do so would radiate that brand essence out to friends, parents, school counselors, industry, and potential employers. They suggest that the core message be about changing lives -- UTI's brand would stand for a confident leader to the students, and would bring them to this change. This potential change/improvement for the student would be illustrated in a sort of three-headed personification -- the student, the instructor, and the manufacturer partner or employer. We then saw a short skit delivered by three actors, cast as one of each of these personifications. Having seen two out of three of these characters up close on the campuses myself, I felt it was pretty convincing (moxie points for this -- it was barely noon!)
From there, the suggestion was to deliver this message by way of a sort of long-lived testimonial execution. The outward facing brand statement was positioned as a sort of call-to-action, following a headline and body copy related to one of each of these three personifications.
This agency's presentation skills were impressive and motivating. The visuals were clean and solid in execution, including their use of typography, power colors, choice of music, video editing, and outside creative references for both brand and messaging. However, it was clear that this particular impression was aimed at a potential new relationship -- I saw some very ordinary work for other accounts on the concept boards in the creative area.
My criticism for Chicago lies in the somewhat underwhelming execution for UTI. They had the tendency to generate a lot of verbal output about past successes (which they have, without a doubt.) In conversation, I felt it was difficult for them to maintain focus on the task at hand -- what else can they do to help us stand apart? I did not expect the volume of creative we saw from Tampa, however the distance between high-level creative concept and tactical execution was not fleshed-out any further in the lively discussion that followed. In addition, their digital creative leader did not seem entirely plugged into the rest of the team.
It was great to finish up by touring their space, and meeting some additional team members. I noticed they do not appear to have facilities for editing and post-production (at least not that they make accessible to their clients.) I did not get a strong hands-on feeling about the development of the creative, or any view into their process or the mind(s) of the executors. They seem deep on traditional talent (ADs, copywriters) but low on digital expertise -- however, I did appreciate the view into a couple of their social media strategies for clients, and how they evolved to produce measurable results.
Of course, lunch was there on the dime. After all, this is Chicago.
Our hosts greeted us warmly in the reception area, where a video message welcomed UTI and each of us by name (it looked as though they were expecting 7, instead of 4). The view was dizzying from up that high, and their work areas are light and open (at least on a day like today). After brief introductions around the table they launched in, presenting a video with testimonials and statements describing what they discovered about us after spending time at the Glendale Heights campus. They took some time to point out a lack of consistency and emotional appeal in our past and current marketing materials. (Yes, and no. But then, we know where we've been.)
They believe that the brand should target the student, and that to do so would radiate that brand essence out to friends, parents, school counselors, industry, and potential employers. They suggest that the core message be about changing lives -- UTI's brand would stand for a confident leader to the students, and would bring them to this change. This potential change/improvement for the student would be illustrated in a sort of three-headed personification -- the student, the instructor, and the manufacturer partner or employer. We then saw a short skit delivered by three actors, cast as one of each of these personifications. Having seen two out of three of these characters up close on the campuses myself, I felt it was pretty convincing (moxie points for this -- it was barely noon!)
From there, the suggestion was to deliver this message by way of a sort of long-lived testimonial execution. The outward facing brand statement was positioned as a sort of call-to-action, following a headline and body copy related to one of each of these three personifications.
This agency's presentation skills were impressive and motivating. The visuals were clean and solid in execution, including their use of typography, power colors, choice of music, video editing, and outside creative references for both brand and messaging. However, it was clear that this particular impression was aimed at a potential new relationship -- I saw some very ordinary work for other accounts on the concept boards in the creative area.
My criticism for Chicago lies in the somewhat underwhelming execution for UTI. They had the tendency to generate a lot of verbal output about past successes (which they have, without a doubt.) In conversation, I felt it was difficult for them to maintain focus on the task at hand -- what else can they do to help us stand apart? I did not expect the volume of creative we saw from Tampa, however the distance between high-level creative concept and tactical execution was not fleshed-out any further in the lively discussion that followed. In addition, their digital creative leader did not seem entirely plugged into the rest of the team.
It was great to finish up by touring their space, and meeting some additional team members. I noticed they do not appear to have facilities for editing and post-production (at least not that they make accessible to their clients.) I did not get a strong hands-on feeling about the development of the creative, or any view into their process or the mind(s) of the executors. They seem deep on traditional talent (ADs, copywriters) but low on digital expertise -- however, I did appreciate the view into a couple of their social media strategies for clients, and how they evolved to produce measurable results.
Of course, lunch was there on the dime. After all, this is Chicago.
Tuesday, April 12, 2011
Tampa, FL
8:45 a.m.: We set out on the tepid, swamp-like stroll from our hotel to the meeting -- first, a tour of what is now this agency's offices, studio, and editing suites. The old building was once the downtown Tampa police headquarters, including an interrogation room with one-way glass, which is these days the agency's main conference room (outfitted with 2-way glass now, thankfully.)
Next we dove into personal introductions and an overview of the agenda, while I gnawed on a rock-hard scone. The agency is around 30 members (creatives and non-creatives). Despite some clear expertise, I found each member of our designated team to be down-to-earth, humble, open to suggestion, flexible, and very enthusiastic (but not in the annoying way.) They were very much dialed into the passion of UTI -- the Brand Strategist and Creative Director spent 3 hours at the Orlando campus and seemed honed-in on what our students, graduates and instructors are thinking and feeling.
While they under-delivered on food (our lunch was apparently stolen en route to its destination), they over-delivered on creative. Their presentation of an overarching statement for the brand and its seven proposed targets (potential student, influencer, employer, industry partner, current student, and alumni) was supported with comps of print ads, brochures, direct mail, television, radio, a social media play, and more -- including urinal ads, complete with customized flush handles. That last one was about bringing the funny to such an intense meeting -- however, with a review team of four women, the laughs had to be prompted.
My criticisms are that the overarching statement might not be exactly what we are after, in tone and focus -- however I am not convinced that they couldn't get there, and I got the sense that they would be interested in doing so and engaged by the process. The messaging was not fleshed-out among the seven targets -- which, although not a deal-breaker, would have been a big hit with us. They clearly have the skills, tools, and ability to deliver. Although the creative approach was not ground-breaking, it was bold, well-structured design in concept. The thought-process behind the messaging was thorough, and I applaud their effort to take one idea and commit to it.
Next we dove into personal introductions and an overview of the agenda, while I gnawed on a rock-hard scone. The agency is around 30 members (creatives and non-creatives). Despite some clear expertise, I found each member of our designated team to be down-to-earth, humble, open to suggestion, flexible, and very enthusiastic (but not in the annoying way.) They were very much dialed into the passion of UTI -- the Brand Strategist and Creative Director spent 3 hours at the Orlando campus and seemed honed-in on what our students, graduates and instructors are thinking and feeling.
While they under-delivered on food (our lunch was apparently stolen en route to its destination), they over-delivered on creative. Their presentation of an overarching statement for the brand and its seven proposed targets (potential student, influencer, employer, industry partner, current student, and alumni) was supported with comps of print ads, brochures, direct mail, television, radio, a social media play, and more -- including urinal ads, complete with customized flush handles. That last one was about bringing the funny to such an intense meeting -- however, with a review team of four women, the laughs had to be prompted.
My criticisms are that the overarching statement might not be exactly what we are after, in tone and focus -- however I am not convinced that they couldn't get there, and I got the sense that they would be interested in doing so and engaged by the process. The messaging was not fleshed-out among the seven targets -- which, although not a deal-breaker, would have been a big hit with us. They clearly have the skills, tools, and ability to deliver. Although the creative approach was not ground-breaking, it was bold, well-structured design in concept. The thought-process behind the messaging was thorough, and I applaud their effort to take one idea and commit to it.
...and they're off!
7:30 a.m.: It's the morning of Day 1. (that's 4:30 am in AZ - no small feat for me, so you know this is a big day.) The flight to Tampa was packed, but it's been smooth sailing -- everyone got in safe and sound. It is 85-90 degrees, with 85-90% humidity. I have tracked down good coffee, and I am prepared to be amazed by Agency Number 1. Stay tuned.
Wednesday, June 16, 2010
Agency week
During the week of April 11–15, I will post reviews of each of the four creative agencies we will be visiting on our whirlwind tour. I will refer to these agencies by city only, and not by name.
Feel free to comment!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)